Whole Food Plant Based Indian Butter Chicken

YouTube video

Whole Food Plant Based Indian Butter Chicken

Jill Dalton
Who doesn’t love a rich creamy Indian sauce. I know our family does but most Indian sauces that are creamy use heavy cream or yogurt. Not this one. I have adapted the classic Butter Chicken recipe into a delicious Nutritarian Salt, Oil, Sugar Free Whole Food Plant Based version (wow that is a mouthful). Mushrooms replace the chicken and as Dr. Fuhrman has pointed out; cooked mushrooms can greatly reduce the chances of breast cancer! Eat up ladies and savor the comforting creamy Mushroom Butter Sauce.
4.50 from 4 votes
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 35 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine Indian
Servings 6 people
Calories 191 kcal



  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  • Drain and press liquid out of tofu between two paper towels.
  • Cut into bit sized chunks and place on a cookie sheet lined with parchment paper.
  • Place in the oven for 15 minutes.
  • Add a little water to saucepan and cook the onions, garlic and mushrooms until translucent.
  • Blend tomatoes, ginger, cashews and soy milk in blender until creamy.
  • Add to the pan with the onion mixture and add the spices and chilies.
  • Add the tofu.
  • Add a cup of water and let sauce cook down until thick and creamy.


Calories: 191kcalCarbohydrates: 23gProtein: 13gFat: 7gSaturated Fat: 1gPolyunsaturated Fat: 2gMonounsaturated Fat: 3gSodium: 295mgPotassium: 927mgFiber: 5gSugar: 11gVitamin A: 430IUVitamin C: 24mgCalcium: 121mgIron: 4mg

29 thoughts on “Whole Food Plant Based Indian Butter Chicken”

  1. Hi Jill – I absolutely love this recipe! It is so delicious and creamy.
    I really like your website and videos. I have made your “crack” dressing and grilled eggplant as well. All amazing!!!!!! Please keep the recipes coming!

  2. Jennifer Jackson

    Could you use coconut milk instead of soy and do you know how that would change the end result?

  3. Hi Jill~ thank goodness I found you! I have been a life long vegetarian, but eating clean/plant based now that I’m in my 50’s with minimal grains was a bit of a struggle in the recipe area as most just didn’t satisfy my taste buds. I am Indian so I wondered how this would taste. Just made it and yes, I added a bit more spices as we Indian’s really like our spicy food, but this was amazing otherwise!! In a separate crock pot as I type I’m also making your Creamy Broccoli and Potato soup (meal prepping for my work week). You have definitely inspired me! Thank you!!!

  4. Just tried this recipe tonight, and my whole family loved it! Even my husband, who is still coming to terms with this Whole Food Plant Based lifestyle, said ” You need to keep this recipe.” When he says something like that, you know its got to be good 🙂 To be honest, I did have to add a little sea salt, b/c we are still trying to ween ourselves off of sooo much sodium, although we have come a long ways b/c we used to need a whole lot more 😉 All in all, this one is definitely a keeper. I also wanted to say that I really appreciate the simplicity of the majority of your recipes. I am a stay-at-home momma of 4 little ones, and this year starting to homeschool our second child in Kindergarten as well as the first one in 2nd grade. I’m sure you can understand the complexity of everyday life, especially when you are trying to make almost all your food from scratch, to make sure the ingredients fit a WFPB criteria. So when I come across your recipes that are simple, not time consuming, delicious, and excellent for your health, I am so grateful. Thank you once again; may the Lord richly bless you!!! 🙂

    1. That is fantastic Jenell! We homeschooled both our girls almost the whole way too. They are now graduated from High school and we are so grateful that we were able to do that for them. I do understand how challenging it can be to juggle all of that and cook healthy meals for everyone so keep up the great work!

  5. It is delicious, I made it tonight and have extra portions for the freeze. I have added 1 zucchini and some fresh spinach I needed to used up. Make 1 1/2 cup serving per person. Thank you!

  6. My family loves this recipe! Thank you for all your wonderful recipes. Not only they are delicious but so easy to prepare!

  7. I made this recipe today, and it is indeed delicious. I wanted to mention that I got a little confused about the amount of tomatoes to use. I usually interpret the ounces in a recipe as referring to the amount of food rather than the weight of the jar. I had only 14.5-oz jars and 28-oz cans of pureed tomatoes. I watched the video and could see that you were using a largish can of tomatoes. I checked the 28-oz can of tomatoes and sure enough, the weight is a little over 1 lb. So I used 28 oz of pureed tomatoes.

    I was wondering whether you used more cashews and soy milk in the video than what are listed in the recipe. Mine turned out fine following the recipe, but I just wanted to check. More cashews and more soymilk probably would have been fine.

    This was my first time making Indian food. And it was a success! Thanks for the great recipe!!!

    1. Thank you for catching that Nancy, I haven’t made that recipe for a while so I didn’t even know that the mistake was there. Sorry for the inconvenience.

      1. Michelle Busa

        Hi Jill,

        Thank you for your site. I have really enjoyed the recipes you have shared. I am just checking back on this recipe. One section indicates 1 16oz can chopped, no salt tomatoes and the ingredient list indicates 1 28oz can chopped, no salt tomatoes. Can you please advise which it is?

  8. Hi Jill, would using almond milk instead of soy milk be a good substitution? I’m wondering if there is a reason one would choose soy instead of almond milk?

    1. I usually use this soy milk because it is literally just soy beans and water. A lot of almond milks out there have a lot of added ingredients but it is perfectly fine to use any kind of plant milk that you choose.=)

  9. Barbara Christopher

    Hi Jill, would tandoori masala work? That is all I have on hand. I like your book, but I notice your videos always add items and techniques, so I watch them before making your dishes. All the dishes I’ve tried are great (the tacos are my favorite which is saying something because I live in El Paso and we know our tacos!)

  10. Jill, I love your cooking show! Everything is so delicious! The indian butter chicken is my husbands absolute favorite. From the Netherlands a very warm greeting, I am very happy with your show, here in the Netherlands plantbased lifestyle and cooking is still a rarity.

  11. Delicious!!! Made this for lunch today and I had to stop myself from taking a third bowl…. gotta safe some for the rest of the family 🙂

  12. Hi Jill. I just made this recipe. I only had Jalapenos on hand and dried ginger. I forgot to add all the spices (OMG, silly me) BUT so far this is my absolute favourite meal !!!!! I miss a lot all those saucy/creamy foods, (you know those like biscuit and gravy type foods). So, this recipe is an absolute winner. Please keep educating us, we really need you. Thank for another great dinner recipe.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *